How John Green won millions of fans (and 4 ways you can build a fanbase, too)

I was scrolling through my daily Publisher’s Weekly a few weeks ago when I spotted the news: John Green is writing a new book called Turtles All the Way Down, and it will be published by Dutton, an imprint of Penguin Random House, on October 10th.

Cue the fan fare! 🎉🎉🎉

Within days of the announcement, Turtles All the Way Down shot up the Amazon bestseller list, and it’s now keeping it’s spot as the #5 bestseller out of all books. John Green is beloved by millions of readers, and he’s the kind of novelist every literary agent and publisher would dream of having on their list. But I’ve always been curious about what makes John Green so successful, other than his writing (because having a great book is always Step 1, but it’s no guarantee your book will breakout.) So how did John Green get to have a fan club of millions of readers, a whole world of fan fiction surrounding his books, and such impressive accolades for his writing?

john green fandom nerdfighters short

If you want to excel at anything, watch the people who are already excelling. But if you want to really get deep and understand what separates the bestselling authors from the struggling authors, you need to talk to their readers.

So today I’m thrilled to have Lydia DuBois on the blog to talk about the 4 things writers can do to build a massive and loyal fan base and readership like John Green. Lydia is a sophomore at the University of Richmond (my alma mater!) and a summer intern at Stonesong, and she’s been working behind-the-scenes to spot great manuscripts in the submissions inbox, scout potential new authors, and learn everything she can about what makes books work. She’s smart as a whip, an avid reader, and a close watcher of the John Green craze of the past few years.

So enough from me–here’s Lydia on what younger readers really think of John Green:

Read More

How John Green built an army of fans (and how any writer can do the same!)

how john green sold so many books

Get one tip for upgrading your literary life sent to your inbox each week!

In case you’ve been living in another galaxy, The Fault In Our Stars movie (based on the eponymous book) debuted in theaters nationwide this weekend. It topped the weekend box office with a $48 million domestic debut, easily crushing Tom Cruise’s new action flick “Edge of Tomorrow,” which did only $29 million in sales. Not bad for a movie geared to a younger audience, with two fairly unknown actors, and an unconventional female protagonist (she has cancer and wears an oxygen tube in her nose).

I think it’s safe to say that the movie was so successful because the book was so successful. But why was the book such a blowout bestseller? Well, my guess is that it’s because John Green has been so successful at building a platform. Which goes to show that, even for fiction writers, building a platform really matters.

Obviously, the book is wonderful, and no amount of platform magic can bolster a lackluster book. But The Fault In Our Stars was a #1 bestseller on Amazon SIX MONTHS before it was even published. That is, thousands of people ordered the book before anyone on the planet had even read it (except for the editor and publishing team, of course).

So why did all those people spend their hard earned money on a book they knew so little about? My theory is simple: they really like John Green. And they really like John Green (and know who he is at all), because of his platform. I’ve seen so many readers, editors, literary agents, and other folks practically swoon when talking about John Green. I don’t see that same visceral, emotionally connected reaction happening for other mega authors, even those with very loyal followings like John Grisham. The difference? One author has a robust, lively, and authentic online platform, and the other not quite as much.

I’m sure 95% of TFiOS book-buyers have never laid eyes on John Green in real life. But millions of his fans see him a few times a week through his hilarious YouTube videos, his blog, and his endless Twitter stream. Those online outlets aren’t just fun hobbies and avenues for self-expression. They’re the pillars of a platform (as I discussed here), and they are powerful tools for connecting with people. They create a direct, one-to-one connection between authors and readers, and they allow readers to feel like they really know an author–like the author is their friend, not just a name on a book jacket. That direct connection is just as valuable for fiction authors as it is for nonfiction authors–who wouldn’t want a whole army of Nerdfighters (or whatever you’d call your army!) ready to support all your work?

But it’s one thing to set up all those accounts and then avoid them like the plague, or feel horribly self-conscious about being your true self on them. But John Green is all over all his social channels every day, and he’s funny and genuine and adorkable. He’s completely himself, and he comes across as just a nice guy. He’s not “marketing” or “engaging with a fanbase”–he’s just talking to his readers, sharing his conversations with his brother, and trying to help people through his work.

The New Yorker profile about how John Green built an army of fans was completely fascinating to me. I will admit that I haven’t read The Fault In Our Stars or seen the movie, but I somehow still teared up at the end of The New Yorker profile. (Yes, I’m a sap.) It’s obvious how much goodwill John Green has earned from his fans, and how he’s done so just by being an accessible and approachable guy. John Green isn’t just out there to sell books–he’s giving his time, energy, and money toward charitable causes; he’s a friend to a girl who died of terminal cancer; he’s a husband and a dad and a brother and a writer. How could anyone not like a guy like that and want to see him succeed?

He also treats his fans like friends, rather than his subjects, which is an incredibly important distinction. He signed the entire first printing of The Fault In Our Stars (that’s 150,000 books, hand-signed), even though it caused him to need physical therapy for his shoulder and would probably have driven the rest of us completely loony. That’s a guy that, in my opinion, feels a strong sense of appreciation for the people who support him and understands that the fandom of a reader is something to be earned. A dedicated readership is not something you’re entitled to simply because you wrote a wonderful book–it’s something you must earn by being in service to the reader.

I thought this passage from The New Yorker profile particularly zeroed in on the difference between the writing life of yore and the new John-Green-esque lifestyle:

“Green’s online projects keep proliferating along with his fans, and he seems determined to keep up with them all. He told me that he has sketched out some scenes for a new novel, about “two male best friends who live less privileged lives in a world of privilege,” and that he hopes to work on it after the movie junkets are over and he has taken a few days of vacation with his family, in a Tennessee farmhouse devoid of electronic devices. One wonders, however, when he’ll actually find the hours to recline in the La-Z-Boy. E. Lockhart, an acclaimed Y.A. novelist, is an old friend of Green’s. She said, “Most of us look at what John does and say ‘That’s awesome,’ but we’d rather be in our pajamas writing.”

While I’m a big believer that periods of unconnectedness from electronic devices are one of the most important sanity-maintainers these days, I think we’re also moving past the days when it was enough to write a great book, publish it, and call it a day. If we all hung out in our pajamas all day, hermited away from the world, we’d miss the sense of connection that drives us as human beings. And we’d also miss the opportunity to help more people through our work. I think authors should remember that platform building isn’t about helping yourself by selling your work, but about helping others through your work.

And the best way to reach the most people is to be, like John Green, both accessible and approachable. Being accessible to your readers means they can find you and connect with you, and being approachable to them means they might just start to really like you, and not just your writing.

Get more insider advice on writing, platform-building, and publishing by signing up below!

Get one tip for upgrading your literary life sent to your inbox each week!